Once upon a time, alpha was everywhere

It appeared in small caps, unloved cyclicals, illiquid bonds, or mispriced convertibles. A sharp analyst and a contrarian view could go a long way. Active managers charged premium fees for uncovering inefficiencies—and many earned them.

But over the past two decades, something shifted. The market stopped responding to narratives and started reacting to flows. As trillions of dollars moved into index funds and ETFs, market movements became more mechanical, less informative.

And while alpha didn’t disappear, it moved—quietly, systematically, and with new rules. It settled in places few were prepared to follow. But unlike in past eras, alpha today is not only harder to find—it’s also constantly on the move.

Passive Takes Over, But Not Without Consequences

The growth of passive investing is well documented:


This shift was driven by:

  • Lower fees (often <10 bps),
  • Simplified asset allocation, and
  • Diminishing active outperformance.

But passive investing isn't passive in its market impact. It buys and sells based on index membership, weightings, and flows—not valuation. This creates systematic, price-insensitive behavior that distorts short-term price discovery and can cause:


Markets didn’t become more rational. They became more structured—and in that structure, a new form of alpha began to take shape.

Alpha Becomes Elusive (But Not Extinct)

Traditional alpha sources have clearly weakened. The share of U.S. mutual funds beating benchmarks over 10 years is less than 10%. Four-factor alpha has turned negative for the average active equity fund . The fraction of stocks with statistically significant positive alpha has declined over the past two decades, reflecting a more challenging environment for active stock selection.

In the hedge fund space, the percentage of funds with significant alpha dropped from approximately 20% before the financial crisis to just 10% after it . These metrics suggest the average fund now struggles to cover its cost, yet this doesn't mean the alpha opportunity itself has vanished. Instead, it's become more fragmented, flow-driven, and systematic.

So where did alpha go?

Alpha Fragments, Reforms, and Reemerges

Alpha today exists across a spectrum of strategies and structures. While recent years have seen standout performance from the large multi-manager hedge funds (MMHFs), they represent just one zone of a broader and evolving ecosystem.

1. Multi-Manager Hedge Funds (MMHFs): Industrialized Alpha

Firms like Citadel, Millennium, DE Shaw, and Balyasny have built platforms that extract small, repeatable alpha signals from market structure and flow distortions. Their advantages are scale, infrastructure, and execution.

But scale comes with risks:

  • Strategies can crowd.
  • Costs rise with size.
  • Flexibility declines.

And while MMHFs have captured alpha in size, they are not guaranteed to do so in the future. In finance, persistent success attracts competition—and compresses opportunity.

2. Quantitative Hedge Funds: Diverse and Adaptive

Outside the mega-platforms, hundreds of quantitative hedge funds deploy:

  • Medium-frequency factor models,
  • Sentiment and alt-data signals,
  • Flow-aware execution strategies.

These firms range from $100 million boutiques to $10 billion franchises, often undervalued by allocators focused on scale. Some trade cross-asset momentum, others exploit seasonality, behavioral finance anomalies, or tail-risk pricing.

The flexibility of smaller quant shops can be a competitive advantage—allowing them to move into underfished markets, adopt new datasets faster, and avoid crowding.

3. Trading & Market-Making Giants

Perhaps the least visible yet most critical alpha extractors are the proprietary trading firms and ETF market makers, including:

  • Jane Street
  • Hudson River Trading
  • Citadel Securities
  • Virtu Financial
  • IMC Trading

These firms are essential to ETF functioning—arbitraging price/NAV gaps, creating and redeeming shares, and absorbing flow-driven dislocations. They don’t manage outside capital, but they do harvest the alpha passive flows create—faster and more precisely than anyone else.

4. Event-Driven, Macro, and Credit Hedge Funds

Other strategies also benefit from passive-induced mispricing:

  • Event-driven funds profit from dislocations around index rebalances, corporate actions, and GICS changes.
  • Macro and vol funds exploit pro-cyclical rebalancing behavior during stress periods.
  • Credit hedge funds capture pricing mismatches in less-liquid bonds, particularly as passive credit ETFs create liquidity illusions.

5. Bank QIS: Systematizing Alpha Access

Investment banks have scaled Quantitative Investment Strategies (QIS)—offering exposure to a wide range of trading strategies.

While often considered “smart beta,” many QIS strategies are engineered to replicate hedge fund return drivers in a more transparent and regulated format. And because QIS is implemented via swaps or notes, it enables institutional access to alpha-like exposures without hedge fund constraints.

Recent years have seen innovation in areas such as dynamic allocation overlays or machine-learning–informed market and volatility timing.

While bank QIS platforms don't always generate headline-grabbing Sharpe ratios, they are a fast-moving frontier, especially for allocators seeking scalable, liquid, and cost-efficient alpha proxies.

6. Experimental and Emerging Strategies

Alpha also lives in places just starting to scale:

  • Decentralized finance (DeFi) and blockchain-based market infrastructure,
  • Alternative data–driven thematic baskets,
  • Event- and regulatory-driven trades in fragmented global markets.

These strategies are often pursued by niche managers, specialist boutiques, and teams spinning out of large institutions. They may underperform today—but represent the vanguard of tomorrow’s edge.

Alpha Is a Moving Target

The key lesson for investment professionals: Alpha is not a static resource—it’s a moving target.

It shifts in response to:

  • Market structure changes (e.g., rise of passive, reg changes),
  • Technological evolution (e.g., data, execution),
  • Competition and capacity,
  • And macro regime changes (e.g., inflation, liquidity cycles).

The big MMHFs and market makers have clearly won the past five years. But that doesn’t guarantee they’ll win the next five. Some alpha streams become overcrowded. Others get commoditized. And new strategies emerge from the periphery.

Today’s dominant pod-shop could be tomorrow’s crowded trade. And today’s overlooked quant boutique or QIS strategy could be tomorrow’s breakthrough.

Implications for Investors and Allocators

What should professional investors do in this constantly shifting landscape?

✅ Stay diversified across alpha types
Don’t overconcentrate in one “winner.” Combine scalable MMHF exposure with QIS, emerging quant, and thematic strategies.

✅ Re-underwrite “smaller” managers
Alpha per dollar of AUM often favors nimble managers. Seek out undercapitalized talent with edge, process, and adaptive infrastructure.

✅ Treat QIS as strategic allocation tools
Bank QIS platforms offer transparent, scalable, rules-based exposures that complement hedge fund allocations—and sometimes outperform them on a Sharpe-adjusted basis.

✅ Monitor where passive is creating new inefficiencies
Look for strategies attuned to ETF flow mechanics, index rebalancing behavior, and cross-asset liquidity fragmentation.

✅ Remember: alpha is cyclical, not dead
The underperformance of traditional active is not proof of alpha’s extinction—it’s a symptom of structural change. Stay curious. Stay humble.

Final Word – Alpha Didn’t Just Migrate. It Evolved.

The rise of passive investing didn’t kill alpha. It redefined it.

Today’s alpha lives in:

  • Structured flows and short-term price pressures,
  • Quant models attuned to behavior, not belief,
  • Fast-moving strategies under the radar of large allocators.

And most importantly—it continues to evolve.

The real edge isn’t just in finding alpha. It’s in understanding how it moves, who’s best positioned to capture it, and how to build a portfolio that’s ready for what comes next.

Subscribe to our Newsletter